Reviewed · WALKING TOURS
Private Old Edinburgh Tour – Walk in the footsteps of Royals and Rogues!
Edinburgh’s Old Town has plenty of secrets. This two-hour private walk brings them out through archive images, sharp local storytelling, and stops tied to Mary, Queen of Scots, Bonnie Prince Charlie, Robert Burns, Burke and Hare, and the city’s grim old justice system. I like the personal pace, and I like that the route includes places many city walks skip, especially the Cowgate and the area around the University of Edinburgh.
The strongest part is the guide, Robert, a lifelong Edinburgh resident and teacher who uses humor, photographs, and even a few props to make the past easier to picture. You should know, though, that this is a walking tour over historic streets and slopes, and its focus on executions, murder, prison life, and poverty may not suit anyone seeking a light introduction to Edinburgh.
In This Review
- Key points at a glance
- Why this private walk works so well
- Starting among the graves at Greyfriars Kirkyard
- Candlemaker Row and the Grassmarket’s darker edge
- Following royal and criminal stories along the Royal Mile
- The Cowgate and Victorian poverty
- Burke, Hare, and the University of Edinburgh
- Robert’s style and the value of a private guide
- Pace, footwear, weather, and meeting details
- Who will get the most from this tour?
- Should you book the Private Old Edinburgh Tour?
- FAQ
- Where does the tour begin?
- Where does the tour end?
- How long does the tour last?
- Is this a private tour?
- What language is offered?
- What is included in the price?
- Is the tour suitable for people with limited mobility?
- Are service animals allowed?
- What happens if the weather is poor?
- Can I cancel for a full refund?
Key points at a glance
- Robert’s local storytelling: Expect clear explanations, humor, personal tips, and a guide who adjusts the pace to your group.
- Three former execution sites: The route tackles Edinburgh’s grim past directly, along with the old Tolbooth Prison and a notorious assassination.
- Archive images along the way: Old photographs help you compare today’s streets with the city that once filled them.
- A truly private format: Only your group takes part, so you can ask questions and set a comfortable walking speed.
- More than the Royal Mile: Greyfriars, the Grassmarket, Cowgate, and the University of Edinburgh all feature in the route.
- A useful first-day orientation: The tour ends on South Bridge, close to the start and well placed for continuing your Old Town sightseeing.
Why this private walk works so well
Edinburgh can feel confusing at first. The Old Town is a layered mix of steep lanes, closes, courtyards, bridges, and broad historic streets, and the most interesting stories are not always marked with a large sign. A private guide gives you a thread to follow.
I like the way this tour connects famous figures to real places. Mary, Queen of Scots is not treated as a distant name from a textbook. Bonnie Prince Charlie appears in connection with the Mercat Cross. Deacon William Brodie becomes more than a name linked to a hanging. The city’s past feels tied to the pavement beneath you.
The archive imagery adds real value. Robert can show you how parts of Edinburgh looked in earlier periods, which helps you notice what has changed and what has survived. This is especially useful in areas where modern buildings or traffic obscure the older story.
The private setup also matters. The price is listed at $117.84 for a group of up to one person, so check the booking terms carefully if you are arranging the walk for more than one person. For a solo visitor, it offers a personal two-hour introduction. For a private group, the value comes from having the guide’s full attention rather than paying for a large general walk.
More Walking Tours in Edinburgh
- Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
★ 4.5 · 8,506 reviews - Edinburgh Castle: Guided Walking Tour with Entry Ticket
★ 5.0 · 5,540 reviews - Edinburgh Castle Guided Walking Tour in English
★ 5.0 · 5,214 reviews
Starting among the graves at Greyfriars Kirkyard

The meeting point is just inside the main gate of Greyfriars Kirkyard on Greyfriars Place. This atmospheric cemetery sits in the heart of Edinburgh’s Old Town, and it gives the tour the right opening mood: quiet, enclosed, and full of stories.
The first focus is Greyfriars Bobby, Edinburgh’s famous little dog. Robert explains that several versions of Bobby’s story exist, then lets you think about which version you believe. That approach is a good sign. Instead of presenting every local legend as settled fact, the tour allows room for doubt and discussion.
You spend about 15 minutes here, with no separate admission charge. The stop is short, but it sets up a key idea for the rest of the walk: Edinburgh’s past is made from records, folklore, public memory, and a fair amount of argument.
The kirkyard itself can be uneven underfoot. You should wear shoes that handle old stone and bring a rain layer. Edinburgh weather can change quickly, and this experience requires suitable conditions to go ahead.
Candlemaker Row and the Grassmarket’s darker edge
From Greyfriars, the route moves toward Candlemaker Row and the Grassmarket. This section lasts around 25 minutes and looks at one of Scotland’s important weddings, along with the route taken by the pre-wedding party.
The value here is the link between a major event and ordinary city movement. You are not simply told that something happened in Edinburgh. You follow the route and see how the streets shaped the occasion.
The Grassmarket also brings you close to the city’s grim public history. The wider tour visits three former execution sites, so this is one of the places where the contrast between today’s lively public square and its harsher past becomes clear. I appreciate that the tour does not polish away the uncomfortable parts of Edinburgh’s story.
The route is not a museum visit, and the stop has no admission charge. You are outside, listening and looking. That means the quality of the experience depends heavily on the guide’s ability to make an ordinary street feel legible, and Robert’s teaching background appears to serve him well.
Following royal and criminal stories along the Royal Mile
The Royal Mile is the longest section of the walk, at about 40 minutes. You visit several locations rather than treating the street as one single sight.
The route includes a place connected with Mary, Queen of Scots’ childhood and a small courtyard with a royal link. These details help you see the Royal Mile as a chain of intimate spaces, not only a long tourist street lined with shops.
Then comes Deacon William Brodie, whose story includes crime and a hanging. His tale is one of the tour’s stranger episodes, and it fits the broader theme of the walk: respectable Edinburgh and criminal Edinburgh often occupied the same narrow streets.
You also receive a brief account of St Giles, followed by the site of the old Mercat Cross. The cross was an important public point, and the story of Bonnie Prince Charlie is tied to this location. This is a useful way to understand how news, power, ceremony, and public opinion once met in the center of town.
The route continues to an atmospheric Old Town close and the former Tolbooth Prison area. The prison was tied to some of Edinburgh’s most notorious stories, including Scotland’s infamous assassination. Expect the tone to become darker here. Robert’s humor helps keep the walk lively, but the material still includes hanging, murder, prison conditions, and public punishment.
A different sort of outing around Edinburgh:
- Edinburgh: Loch Ness, Glencoe & the Scottish Highlands Tour
★ 4.6 · 17,446 reviews - From Edinburgh: Loch Ness, Glencoe & Scottish Highlands Tour
★ 4.7 · 11,381 reviews - The World Famous Underground Ghost Tour
★ 4.5 · 9,272 reviews - Loch Ness, Scottish Highlands, Glencoe and Pitlochry Tour
★ 5.0 · 6,854 reviews
The Cowgate and Victorian poverty
Many Old Town walks stay on the Royal Mile. This one turns down to the Cowgate for roughly 10 minutes, looking at life among Edinburgh’s Victorian poor.
The stop is brief, but it widens the tour beyond royals, rebels, and notorious criminals. You get a sense of how the city worked for people who had little power and few choices. That social angle is important because grand events can make Edinburgh’s past seem like a parade of famous names.
The Cowgate can feel rougher and less polished than the main tourist streets. That is part of its usefulness. You are seeing a less tidy side of the Old Town, one that helps explain why the city’s historic reputation includes overcrowding, deprivation, and hard living.
If you prefer a tour focused only on grand architecture, this section may seem less scenic. If you want a fuller picture of how people lived, it is one of the more worthwhile turns in the route.
Burke, Hare, and the University of Edinburgh
The final part of the tour takes in two University of Edinburgh stops and lasts around 30 minutes. The main story concerns Burke and Hare, the infamous Irish murderers whose crimes became linked to the demand for bodies used in medical study.
Robert explains how the pair operated, why they were able to murder so many people, and what eventually happened to them. This is not a quick name check. The story is used to explain a wider problem involving medicine, poverty, and the value placed on human bodies.
The route may also include a look at the traditional Highland outfit Robert wears. That small detail adds a bit of fun after some very grim material. His kilt and humor have become part of the experience for many groups, but the real strength remains his ability to explain the setting clearly.
The final stop is near Old College, or inside it if access is available. The building looks impressive today, but the story connected with it is even more explosive, literally. Since entry depends on whether the interior is open to the group, you should treat the inside visit as a possibility rather than a guarantee.
This section gives the tour a strong finish. You move from royal stories and public executions to the relationship between Edinburgh’s university, medicine, crime, and social class. It also leaves you near South Bridge, about 10 minutes from the starting point.
Robert’s style and the value of a private guide
Robert receives the strongest praise for his warmth, humor, clear explanations, and ability to tailor the walk. He asks about your interests and adjusts the route’s pace to suit your group. That is useful if you want more time for questions, need a slower walk, or prefer certain themes.
His teaching background shows in the way the stories are explained. You get facts, but also a reason to care about them. Props and archive images help break up the talking, and his local connection gives the tour a personal feel without turning it into a vague collection of legends.
The private format is especially helpful for families and small groups. One group appreciated that children were engaged and asked many questions. Another visitor who was the only person to show up still received a full private experience, with the two hours passing quickly through stories and humor.
You should not expect a silent, solemn academic lecture. Robert’s style is personable and at times irreverent. That works well for many people, but if you prefer a strictly formal presentation, his lively approach may feel less restrained.
Pace, footwear, weather, and meeting details
The tour lasts approximately two hours. Since the stops total about two hours and the route ends on South Bridge, you should allow a little flexibility around the finish if you have a tight restaurant booking or timed attraction afterward.
The walk begins at the main gate of Greyfriars Kirkyard Cemetery, Greyfriars Place, Edinburgh EH1 2QQ. It ends on South Bridge, normally about 10 minutes from the start. The area is near public transportation, but this is still a walking experience through historic streets.
A moderate level of physical fitness is recommended. You do not need to rush, and the guide can adapt the pace, but old Edinburgh includes slopes, steps, uneven paving, and tight passages. Sensible shoes matter more than fashionable ones.
Service animals are allowed. The experience is offered in English and uses a mobile ticket. It is dependent on good weather. If poor weather forces cancellation, you are offered another date or a full refund.
Free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start time. Changes or cancellations inside that window are not accepted for a refund, so keep an eye on the local start time.
Who will get the most from this tour?
I would choose this walk if you want Edinburgh’s stories delivered by one person who can respond to your questions. It suits first-time visitors who want an orientation, solo visitors who dislike joining a large group, and families who benefit from a flexible pace.
It is also a good fit if you have already seen Edinburgh Castle and the main Royal Mile sights but want more context around the surrounding streets. The route gives you royal connections, crime, poverty, medicine, public punishment, and local folklore in one compact walk.
You may want another tour if your main goal is interior access to major buildings, a broad survey of Scottish art, or a route centered on architecture alone. Most of this experience takes place outdoors, and the route’s appeal comes from stories tied to streets and places rather than ticketed attractions.
The subject matter deserves a warning. Executions, murder, prison life, and poverty are central, not occasional side notes. That makes the tour memorable, but it may not be right for young children or anyone who wants a gentle city stroll.
Should you book the Private Old Edinburgh Tour?
Book it if you value a strong guide more than a long list of admissions. Robert’s humor, local background, archive images, and flexible pace turn a simple Old Town walk into a connected story about how Edinburgh lived, punished, celebrated, and survived.
At $117.84 for a group of up to one person, the price needs a careful look if your booking includes more than one person. For a solo visitor wanting personal attention, the format is appealing. The tour has a five-star rating from 229 reviews and a 100 percent recommendation rate, which supports the impression of a consistently well-liked experience.
I would especially book it early if your dates are fixed, since it is commonly reserved well ahead of time. Choose sturdy footwear, dress for changing weather, and come ready for grim stories as well as royal drama. If that sounds like your kind of Edinburgh, this is a smart two-hour introduction.
FAQ
Where does the tour begin?
It begins just inside the main gate of Greyfriars Kirkyard Cemetery on Greyfriars Place, Edinburgh EH1 2QQ.
Where does the tour end?
It usually ends on South Bridge, about 10 minutes from the starting point at Greyfriars Kirkyard.
How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately two hours.
Is this a private tour?
Yes. Only your group participates in this private tour or activity.
What language is offered?
The tour is offered in English.
What is included in the price?
A local guide is included. Admission tickets are not charged for the listed stops.
Is the tour suitable for people with limited mobility?
A moderate level of physical fitness is recommended. The tour takes place on historic Old Town streets, so you should be prepared for walking on uneven surfaces and slopes.
Are service animals allowed?
Yes, service animals are allowed.
What happens if the weather is poor?
The experience requires good weather. If it is canceled because of poor weather, you are offered a different date or a full refund.
Can I cancel for a full refund?
Yes, if you cancel at least 24 hours before the experience start time. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not accepted for a refund.
Recently added around Edinburgh
- Fantastic Creatures of Edinburgh, and where to find them!★ 4.5 · 55 reviews
- From Edinburgh: Islay and The Whisky Coast 4-Day Tour★ 4.9 · 55 reviews
- ‘A Wee Pedal’s’ Family Friendly Cycle Tour to Edinburgh’s Coast★ 5.0 · 55 reviews
- Edinburgh Historical Gems Tour with Whisky & Local Flavours★ 5.0 · 56 reviews
- Edinburgh: Bamburgh Castle, Northumberland and Alnwick Trip★ 4.6 · 56 reviews
- Scottish Highlands Freedom Bike & E- Bike Tour with Transfers★ 5.0 · 56 reviews
- 2-Day Outlander Experience Small Group Tour from Edinburgh★ 5.0 · 57 reviews
- The Best Food Tour in Edinburgh★ 4.5 · 57 reviews
Walking Tours, compared.

Magical London: Harry Potter Guided Walking Tour
Read our review →
Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
Read our review →
Oxford University Walking Tour With University Alumni Guide
Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle: Guided Walking Tour with Entry Ticket
Read our review →
Edinburgh Castle Guided Walking Tour in English
Read our review →
Tour for Muggles The Ultimate Harry Potter Walking Tour in London
Read our review →
University and City Walking Tour with Alumni Guide
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in

